Skip to content

feat(experimental): Implement separate -Zownership analysis for ownership pass#7861

Merged
jfecher merged 80 commits intomasterfrom
jf/ownership-experimental
Apr 15, 2025
Merged

feat(experimental): Implement separate -Zownership analysis for ownership pass#7861
jfecher merged 80 commits intomasterfrom
jf/ownership-experimental

Conversation

@jfecher
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

@jfecher jfecher commented Mar 31, 2025

Description

Problem*

Working towards #7321

Summary*

Extends the ownership pass (added in #7860) to implement some experimental ownership semantics that change where we clone things, enabled by the -Zownership flag.

Terminology note: clone refers to where we insert inc_rcs, brillig's reference counting & copy on write semantics remain the same, although actual reference counts may differ.

With this flag set:

  • Clones occur moreso where one coming from Rust may expect. Normally these happen when a variable is used multiple times or when a dereference occurs.
  • A last use analysis is done so that we move the last instance of a variable instead of clone it unnecessarily.
  • We still clone implicitly. Since chore(debug): Add ownership analysis pass #7860 we can at least --show-monomorphized to see where clones are inserted.

Edit: Also see #7951 for brillig performance differences of -Zownership versus master

Additional Context

The main changes in this PR for reviewing are:

  • The new last_uses pass which is done on each function before the ownership pass only if -Zownership is set. It's purpose is to find where we can move variables instead of cloning.
  • The changes to the ownership pass to clone in different places depending on whether experimental_ownership_feature is set.

Documentation*

Check one:

  • No documentation needed.
  • Documentation included in this PR.
  • [For Experimental Features] Documentation to be submitted in a separate PR.

PR Checklist*

  • I have tested the changes locally.
  • I have formatted the changes with Prettier and/or cargo fmt on default settings.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

@github-actions github-actions bot left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

⚠️ Performance Alert ⚠️

Possible performance regression was detected for benchmark 'Test Suite Duration'.
Benchmark result of this commit is worse than the previous benchmark result exceeding threshold 1.20.

Benchmark suite Current: 3012838 Previous: def2e8c Ratio
zkemail_noir-jwt_ 5 s 2 s 2.50

This comment was automatically generated by workflow using github-action-benchmark.

CC: @TomAFrench

jfecher and others added 3 commits April 14, 2025 13:04
Co-authored-by: Maxim Vezenov <mvezenov@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Maxim Vezenov <mvezenov@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Maxim Vezenov <mvezenov@gmail.com>
@github-actions
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

github-actions bot commented Apr 14, 2025

Changes to number of Brillig opcodes executed

Generated at commit: e82fcdfe0fe1396ca3c20a8d63168c7a4e605288, compared to commit: 7211e767d62f3552814432fb3b1cb1e2baeee719

🧾 Summary (10% most significant diffs)

Program Brillig opcodes (+/-) %
slice_regex_inliner_zero -108 ✅ -2.70%
slice_regex_inliner_max -88 ✅ -2.73%

Full diff report 👇
Program Brillig opcodes (+/-) %
slice_dynamic_index_inliner_min 4,571 (-4) -0.09%
slice_dynamic_index_inliner_max 4,331 (-4) -0.09%
slice_dynamic_index_inliner_zero 4,331 (-4) -0.09%
slice_regex_inliner_min 8,330 (-108) -1.28%
slice_regex_inliner_zero 3,889 (-108) -2.70%
slice_regex_inliner_max 3,132 (-88) -2.73%

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

@TomAFrench TomAFrench left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Nit plus we could probably benefit from some quick testing of the last_uses pass. Testing exact values for the IdentId is probably not the most useful but at least we can track structure.

Otherwise LGTM

Comment thread compiler/noirc_frontend/src/ownership/mod.rs Outdated
Comment thread compiler/noirc_frontend/src/ownership/last_uses.rs
Comment thread compiler/noirc_frontend/src/ownership/last_uses.rs
Co-authored-by: Tom French <15848336+TomAFrench@users.noreply.github.com>
@jfecher jfecher enabled auto-merge April 14, 2025 20:31
@jfecher jfecher added this pull request to the merge queue Apr 15, 2025
@github-merge-queue github-merge-queue bot removed this pull request from the merge queue due to failed status checks Apr 15, 2025
@jfecher jfecher added this pull request to the merge queue Apr 15, 2025
Merged via the queue into master with commit 8c4a83a Apr 15, 2025
113 checks passed
@jfecher jfecher deleted the jf/ownership-experimental branch April 15, 2025 15:40
github-merge-queue bot pushed a commit to AztecProtocol/aztec-packages that referenced this pull request Apr 22, 2025
Automated pull of nightly from the
[noir](https://github.com/noir-lang/noir) programming language, a
dependency of Aztec.
BEGIN_COMMIT_OVERRIDE
fix(brillig): SliceRefCount reads from the appropriate pointer
(noir-lang/noir#8148)
chore: remove try_merge_only_changed_indices
(noir-lang/noir#8142)
chore(ssa): Test terminator value constant folding and resolve cache for
data bus (noir-lang/noir#8132)
chore: parse nop in SSA parser
(noir-lang/noir#8141)
fix(ssa): Do not inline simple recursive functions
(noir-lang/noir#8127)
fix: wrapping mul support for u128
(noir-lang/noir#7941)
chore: update ACVM doc (noir-lang/noir#8004)
fix(ssa): Loop range with u1
(noir-lang/noir#8131)
fix(acir): Check whether opcodes were laid down for non-equality check
before fetching payload locations
(noir-lang/noir#8133)
chore: add a benchmark for opcodes which need a batchable inversion
(noir-lang/noir#8110)
chore: create module for array handling in acirgen
(noir-lang/noir#8119)
feat: avoid unnecessary zero check in brillig overflow check
(noir-lang/noir#8109)
chore(optimization): Enable experimental ownership clone scheme by
default (noir-lang/noir#8097)
chore(experimental): Function::simple_optimization for SSA optimizations
(noir-lang/noir#8102)
feat: replace field divisions by constants with multiplication by inv…
(noir-lang/noir#8053)
fix(ssa): fix possibility to `Field % Field` operaions in Brillig from
SSA (noir-lang/noir#8105)
fix(parser): error on missing let semicolon in trait (and others)
(noir-lang/noir#8101)
chore: simpler `make_mutable` in `array_set` optimization
(noir-lang/noir#8106)
chore(docs): update bb commands to match 0.84.0
(noir-lang/noir#8050)
chore: don't use `set_value_from_id` in `constant_folding`
(noir-lang/noir#8091)
fix: add proper handling for `u128` in comptime interpreter
(noir-lang/noir#8079)
feat: Port callstack resolution from aztec to noirjs
(noir-lang/noir#7642)
fix(ssa): Do not unroll loop with break
(noir-lang/noir#8090)
feat: `#[allow(dead_code)]`
(noir-lang/noir#8066)
chore: don't use `set_value_from_id` in `loop_invariant`
(noir-lang/noir#8085)
feat(experimental): Implement separate `-Zownership` analysis for
ownership pass (noir-lang/noir#7861)
chore(docs): Add architecture docs
(noir-lang/noir#7992)
chore: don't use `set_value_from_id` in `simplify_cfg`
(noir-lang/noir#8072)
chore: don't use `set_from_value_id` in `remove_if_else`
(noir-lang/noir#8070)
chore: don't use `set_value_from_id` in `remove_bit_shifts`
(noir-lang/noir#8071)
fix: replace values in data_bus too
(noir-lang/noir#8086)
chore: bump bignum timeout (noir-lang/noir#8080)
chore: Accept optional test path for emitting integration tests
(noir-lang/noir#8062)
feat: ssa fuzzer (noir-lang/noir#7641)
fix: Allow more slack in AST calibration for CI
(noir-lang/noir#8076)
chore: Print `unsafe { ... }` around calls to Brillig from ACIR in AST
(noir-lang/noir#8077)
fix: SSA pass print filter to include the count
(noir-lang/noir#8074)
END_COMMIT_OVERRIDE

---------

Co-authored-by: AztecBot <tech@aztecprotocol.com>
Co-authored-by: Tom French <15848336+TomAFrench@users.noreply.github.com>
github-merge-queue bot pushed a commit to AztecProtocol/aztec-packages that referenced this pull request Apr 24, 2025
🤖 I have created a new Aztec Packages release
---


##
[0.86.0](v0.85.0...v0.86.0)
(2025-04-24)


### ⚠ BREAKING CHANGES

* Use combined p2p and http prover coordination
([#13760](#13760))
* use single extended viem client
([#13715](#13715))
* remove slice read from CALL
([#13729](#13729))

### Features

* `#[allow(dead_code)]` (noir-lang/noir#8066)
([366d980](366d980))
* add aztec-up amm test w/ proving & sponsoredfpc
([#13209](#13209))
([f54c8a1](f54c8a1))
* Add Rollup to registry and produce blocks
([#13556](#13556))
([9ed10d3](9ed10d3))
* adding devnet tests
([#12808](#12808))
([7687a1f](7687a1f))
* audit tracking tooling
([#13639](#13639))
([e50d8e0](e50d8e0))
* **avm:** fast entity indexing without macros
([#13737](#13737))
([5c8a993](5c8a993))
* **avm:** quick n dirty memory trace
([#13659](#13659))
([062c6a9](062c6a9))
* **avm:** support col arrays and add keccak cols
([#13711](#13711))
([9c4345a](9c4345a))
* **avm:** tagged value type in C++
([#13540](#13540))
([b30b5b3](b30b5b3))
* avoid unnecessary zero check in brillig overflow check
(noir-lang/noir#8109)
([366d980](366d980))
* **contracts:** static + snapshotted validator set
([#13046](#13046))
([90033f2](90033f2))
* enable mempool limiter on devnet
([#13722](#13722))
([36fb0a1](36fb0a1))
* exec opcode spec table
([#13594](#13594))
([d4d503a](d4d503a))
* **experimental:** Implement separate `-Zownership` analysis for
ownership pass (noir-lang/noir#7861)
([366d980](366d980))
* expose mempool limit through helm chart
([#13616](#13616))
([822e8d9](822e8d9))
* Garaga UltraStarknet[Zk]Honk flavours
([#11489](#11489))
([6bc34a1](6bc34a1))
* IPA claim as public component
([#13429](#13429))
([1ce3c43](1ce3c43))
* no longer recompute vk's in CIVC proofs
([#13590](#13590))
([66a61ba](66a61ba))
* **p2p:** add private peers
([#12585](#12585))
([4264c8c](4264c8c))
* **p2p:** optional P2P_BROADCAST_PORT
([#13525](#13525))
([f709fab](f709fab))
* Port callstack resolution from aztec to noirjs
(noir-lang/noir#7642)
([366d980](366d980))
* Refactor IPA claim handling in acir format to support them for AVM
([#13547](#13547))
([df73c05](df73c05))
* remove slice read from CALL
([#13729](#13729))
([7e7eb85](7e7eb85))
* replace field divisions by constants with multiplication by inv…
(noir-lang/noir#8053)
([366d980](366d980))
* report world state size on disk
([#13706](#13706))
([0dd8a7e](0dd8a7e))
* skip inverting field elements with values +-1 in ACVM
(noir-lang/noir#8049)
([44c1347](44c1347))
* SMT Verificaiton Module: Data Structures
([#13658](#13658))
([2de3bc5](2de3bc5))
* SMT verification module updates
([#13551](#13551))
([f02123d](f02123d))
* ssa fuzzer (noir-lang/noir#7641)
([366d980](366d980))
* Tighter timing on ACVM
([#13743](#13743))
([45cd39b](45cd39b))
* track rewards and slots
([#13546](#13546))
([489c6cf](489c6cf))
* Use combined p2p and http prover coordination
([#13760](#13760))
([4d04e62](4d04e62))
* VK generation test for HonkRecursionConstraint
([#13637](#13637))
([71e81ce](71e81ce))


### Bug Fixes

* **acir:** Check whether opcodes were laid down for non-equality check
before fetching payload locations
(noir-lang/noir#8133)
([366d980](366d980))
* add proper handling for `u128` in comptime interpreter
(noir-lang/noir#8079)
([366d980](366d980))
* Add version to gossipsub protocol
([#13567](#13567))
([8ce4829](8ce4829))
* allow keywords in function names in SSA parser
(noir-lang/noir#8063)
([44c1347](44c1347))
* Allow more slack in AST calibration for CI
(noir-lang/noir#8076)
([366d980](366d980))
* amm bot
([#13553](#13553))
([6b93832](6b93832)),
closes
[#13544](#13544)
* **avm:** cpp addressing
([#13652](#13652))
([9d941b6](9d941b6))
* blob sink waits for reg address when needed
([#13628](#13628))
([486a42a](486a42a))
* **brillig:** SliceRefCount reads from the appropriate pointer
(noir-lang/noir#8148)
([366d980](366d980))
* Check against multiple aws profiles in build instance credentails
([#13421](#13421))
([71a408a](71a408a))
* dependency cycles in public simulator - part 0 (sim -&gt; context)
([#13678](#13678))
([e00089f](e00089f))
* dependency cycles in public simulator - part 1 (errors/revertReason)
([#13679](#13679))
([c75e365](c75e365))
* dependency cycles in public simulator part 2 (serializable bytecode)
([#13680](#13680))
([5d3e24c](5d3e24c))
* discv5 test failure
([#13653](#13653))
([58c143b](58c143b))
* **docs:** Make viewing (outdated) protocol specs work locally
([#13534](#13534))
([694537d](694537d))
* Increase timeout for p2p integration test
([#13720](#13720))
([c244b2e](c244b2e))
* mac bb --version
([#13690](#13690))
([9f8b64f](9f8b64f))
* make translator use ultra rather than eccvm ops
([#13489](#13489))
([53c070d](53c070d))
* more worker fixes
([#13759](#13759))
([080485a](080485a))
* move helm lint to build
([#13532](#13532))
([7768ff8](7768ff8))
* native ivc benches not publishing
([#13665](#13665))
([7ab712d](7ab712d))
* no exports of simulator should depend on jest-mock-extended
([#13694](#13694))
([65a9f33](65a9f33))
* only clear trailing zeros on logs
([#13727](#13727))
([e392d7c](e392d7c))
* **p2p:** better batch connection sampling
([#13674](#13674))
([9c1d9f1](9c1d9f1))
* **p2p:** reqresp types + batch request tx pool filtering
([#13666](#13666))
([8e2a3c9](8e2a3c9))
* **parser:** error on missing let semicolon in trait (and others)
(noir-lang/noir#8101)
([366d980](366d980))
* pass along coinbase
([#13560](#13560))
([593f810](593f810)),
closes
[#13643](#13643)
* prover-node start
([#13627](#13627))
([5d87f7a](5d87f7a))
* quote numbers
([#13654](#13654))
([f0d1ec1](f0d1ec1))
* remove all txs from a failed epoch
([#13771](#13771))
([abc4623](abc4623))
* remove insecure dummy round derivation from sumcheck and shplemini
([#13488](#13488))
([9a3bb46](9a3bb46))
* replace values in data_bus too
(noir-lang/noir#8086)
([366d980](366d980))
* retry deploy npm
([#13691](#13691))
([76cab3f](76cab3f))
* run yarn
([#13713](#13713))
([0e51259](0e51259))
* squash nightly foundry warning
([#13640](#13640))
([e21f9fd](e21f9fd))
* SSA pass print filter to include the count
(noir-lang/noir#8074)
([366d980](366d980))
* **ssa:** Do not inline simple recursive functions
(noir-lang/noir#8127)
([366d980](366d980))
* **ssa:** Do not unroll loop with break
(noir-lang/noir#8090)
([366d980](366d980))
* **ssa:** Do not use inner else condition when collapsing IfElse based
upon the then condition (noir-lang/noir#8040)
([44c1347](44c1347))
* **ssa:** fix possibility to `Field % Field` operaions in Brillig from
SSA (noir-lang/noir#8105)
([366d980](366d980))
* **ssa:** Loop range with u1
(noir-lang/noir#8131)
([366d980](366d980))
* update metric name to avoid conflicts
([#13629](#13629))
([70c58ab](70c58ab)),
closes
[#13626](#13626)
* wasm memory benchmark
([#13573](#13573))
([9a73c4a](9a73c4a))
* wrapping mul support for u128
(noir-lang/noir#7941)
([366d980](366d980))


### Miscellaneous

* Accept optional test path for emitting integration tests
(noir-lang/noir#8062)
([366d980](366d980))
* Add `GITHUB_TOKEN` to more workflow steps
(noir-lang/noir#8046)
([44c1347](44c1347))
* add a benchmark for opcodes which need a batchable inversion
(noir-lang/noir#8110)
([366d980](366d980))
* add hacky faster bootstrap for bb-centric e2e flow
([#13587](#13587))
([498d433](498d433))
* address some visibility warnings
([#13728](#13728))
([35dec90](35dec90))
* **avm:** less codegen for lookups
([#13741](#13741))
([ec468d9](ec468d9))
* **avm:** move interaction jobs to trace builders
([#13621](#13621))
([caac1c9](caac1c9))
* bb.js non-inlined web workers
([#13736](#13736))
([0e604a1](0e604a1))
* **bb:** debugging helpers
([#13584](#13584))
([0ebb29e](0ebb29e))
* **bb:** Make goblin a proper source module
([#13580](#13580))
([3048a14](3048a14))
* bespoke export for client native prover / PXE server store lazy load
([#13783](#13783))
([640dd08](640dd08))
* Blob and archiver syncing improvements
([#13542](#13542))
([629aa2a](629aa2a)),
closes
[#13530](#13530)
* blob archive client factory code
([#13648](#13648))
([7b16791](7b16791))
* bug list
([#13773](#13773))
([c6d4fb8](c6d4fb8))
* bump axois
([#13453](#13453))
([1c20920](1c20920))
* bump bb to 0.84.0 (noir-lang/noir#8047)
([44c1347](44c1347))
* bump bignum timeout (noir-lang/noir#8080)
([366d980](366d980))
* bump external pinned commits
(noir-lang/noir#8045)
([44c1347](44c1347))
* **ci:** run non dependent bootstrap build steps in parallel
([#13454](#13454))
([b17e18d](b17e18d))
* cleanup aztec up amm test
([#13754](#13754))
([3d92afe](3d92afe))
* Cleanup scripts in package jsons in yarn-project
([#13527](#13527))
([a296945](a296945))
* **contracts:** core/staking -&gt; core/slashing
([#13748](#13748))
([5d93a0e](5d93a0e))
* create module for array handling in acirgen
(noir-lang/noir#8119)
([366d980](366d980))
* dashboards use ${data_source} variable
([#13613](#13613))
([45533d9](45533d9))
* delete honk_recursion for building ACIR
([#13664](#13664))
([ac95729](ac95729))
* delete Ultra Vanilla CIVC
([#13669](#13669))
([ae578a2](ae578a2))
* delete zeromorph
([#13667](#13667))
([c8acae0](c8acae0))
* Disable blobscan by default
([#13742](#13742))
([c55088e](c55088e))
* **docs:** `aztec` and `aztec-wallet` cli reference updates
([#13692](#13692))
([d11d154](d11d154))
* **docs:** add 0.85.0 docs
([#13578](#13578))
([cf07358](cf07358))
* **docs:** add AND/XOR bug to bug list
([#13784](#13784))
([797ae6d](797ae6d))
* **docs:** Add architecture docs
(noir-lang/noir#7992)
([366d980](366d980))
* **docs:** adding redirects for node guide
([#13768](#13768))
([e96e5bf](e96e5bf))
* **docs:** bugfix + deploy on master
([#13717](#13717))
([010975a](010975a))
* **docs:** Fix some stuff on fees, rm confusing storage example
([#13501](#13501))
([c00b20b](c00b20b))
* **docs:** Sequencer and Prover Guide
([#13433](#13433))
([55b9a2b](55b9a2b))
* **docs:** update bb commands to match 0.84.0
(noir-lang/noir#8050)
([366d980](366d980))
* **docs:** Update docs bootrap to to include release
([#13615](#13615))
([2154d5e](2154d5e))
* don't use `set_from_value_id` in `remove_if_else`
(noir-lang/noir#8070)
([366d980](366d980))
* don't use `set_value_from_id` in `as_slice_length`
(noir-lang/noir#8039)
([44c1347](44c1347))
* don't use `set_value_from_id` in `constant_folding`
(noir-lang/noir#8091)
([366d980](366d980))
* don't use `set_value_from_id` in `loop_invariant`
(noir-lang/noir#8085)
([366d980](366d980))
* don't use `set_value_from_id` in `remove_bit_shifts`
(noir-lang/noir#8071)
([366d980](366d980))
* don't use `set_value_from_id` in `simplify_cfg`
(noir-lang/noir#8072)
([366d980](366d980))
* **experimental:** Function::simple_optimization for SSA optimizations
(noir-lang/noir#8102)
([366d980](366d980))
* Fetch rollup address using version as index
([#13620](#13620))
([60e73f9](60e73f9))
* Fix license files
([#13695](#13695))
([9931fb8](9931fb8))
* mempool limit
([#13735](#13735))
([def1287](def1287))
* mint block rewards for 200K blocks at deployment
([#13537](#13537))
([1a3a326](1a3a326))
* move check_circuit functionality from `TranslatorCircuitBuilder` into
a `TranslatorCircuitChecker`
([#13761](#13761))
([e4e7fca](e4e7fca))
* noir test flake addition
([#13663](#13663))
([c302fdd](c302fdd))
* **noir-contracts:** update readme
([#13563](#13563))
([42dfbbf](42dfbbf))
* **optimization:** Enable experimental ownership clone scheme by
default (noir-lang/noir#8097)
([366d980](366d980))
* parse nop in SSA parser (noir-lang/noir#8141)
([366d980](366d980))
* ping luke instead of cody on bb benchmark regressions
([#13718](#13718))
([2802f5a](2802f5a))
* playground improvements
([#13588](#13588))
([4c3453b](4c3453b))
* **playground:** bump vite
([#13750](#13750))
([7e72420](7e72420))
* Print `unsafe { ... }` around calls to Brillig from ACIR in AST
(noir-lang/noir#8077)
([366d980](366d980))
* **public/avm:** from hints to the end of the world
([#13459](#13459))
([a89de5d](a89de5d))
* redo typo PR by dizer-ti
([#13757](#13757))
([075d3a8](075d3a8))
* release playground on s3.
([#13582](#13582))
([2f9458a](2f9458a))
* **release:** give aztec release image sensible default entrypoint
([#13517](#13517))
([a864c06](a864c06))
* remove circuit simulator
([#13689](#13689))
([a00566c](a00566c))
* Remove code of the fake AVM recursive verifier
([#13614](#13614))
([048dfed](048dfed))
* remove msm sorter
([#13668](#13668))
([ff29d86](ff29d86))
* remove old terraform configs
([#13716](#13716))
([49ac1db](49ac1db)),
closes
[#13651](#13651)
* remove omit param from serialize derivation
([#13703](#13703))
([6af5943](6af5943))
* remove pcs vk from vk
([#13638](#13638))
([0e941ef](0e941ef))
* remove try_merge_only_changed_indices
(noir-lang/noir#8142)
([366d980](366d980))
* replace relative paths to noir-protocol-circuits
([78c87b5](78c87b5))
* replace relative paths to noir-protocol-circuits
([4e53cd1](4e53cd1))
* replace relative paths to noir-protocol-circuits
([3a33c47](3a33c47))
* replace relative paths to noir-protocol-circuits
([eaaa85b](eaaa85b))
* replace relative paths to noir-protocol-circuits
([648a4fe](648a4fe))
* replace relative paths to noir-protocol-circuits
([b3f4745](b3f4745))
* replace relative paths to noir-protocol-circuits
([269b316](269b316))
* replace relative paths to noir-protocol-circuits
([1330efe](1330efe))
* replace relative paths to noir-protocol-circuits
([a739284](a739284))
* Sanity check block number from archiver before returning it
([#13631](#13631))
([e459b2a](e459b2a))
* simpler `make_mutable` in `array_set` optimization
(noir-lang/noir#8106)
([366d980](366d980))
* **spartan:** bump default kind resources
([#13747](#13747))
([8ca828f](8ca828f))
* **ssa:** Additional unrolling and mem2reg passes
(noir-lang/noir#8017)
([44c1347](44c1347))
* **ssa:** Remove IfElse pass basic SSA tests
(noir-lang/noir#8058)
([44c1347](44c1347))
* **ssa:** Test terminator value constant folding and resolve cache for
data bus (noir-lang/noir#8132)
([366d980](366d980))
* starknet feature flag
([#13681](#13681))
([2b6c627](2b6c627))
* stop prover node swallowing start prover job errors
([#13676](#13676))
([90c2b7b](90c2b7b))
* **test:** AST generation calibration test
(noir-lang/noir#8054)
([44c1347](44c1347))
* update ACVM doc (noir-lang/noir#8004)
([366d980](366d980))
* Update docs snippet
([#13739](#13739))
([7fb333a](7fb333a))
* update staking asset handler address
([#13566](#13566))
([daa09f2](daa09f2))
* Updated contract addresses for alpha-testnet
([#13585](#13585))
([9f0ff4a](9f0ff4a))
* Use chain monitor to sync system time in p2p tests
([#13632](#13632))
([abbad4c](abbad4c))
* use public component key for pairing inputs
([#13705](#13705))
([467166f](467166f))
* use PublicComponentKeys
([#13686](#13686))
([68e4b6f](68e4b6f))
* use single extended viem client
([#13715](#13715))
([cf637dc](cf637dc))
* validate block header hash in circuits
([#13094](#13094))
([f19c182](f19c182))
* wasm proof verifying with native bb
([#13499](#13499))
([1ad9249](1ad9249))


### Documentation

* fees tutorial
([#13357](#13357))
([c580657](c580657))
* move snippets all versions
([#13650](#13650))
([a2f5553](a2f5553))
* Update glossary & snippets
([#13661](#13661))
([d55816d](d55816d))

---
This PR was generated with [Release
Please](https://github.com/googleapis/release-please). See
[documentation](https://github.com/googleapis/release-please#release-please).

---------

Co-authored-by: AztecBot <tech@aztecprotocol.com>
@Savio-Sou
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

This should be a "[For Experimental Features] Documentation to be submitted in a separate PR", rather than a "No documentation needed" if I understand it correctly? (That is, useful for Noir users to know but not now.)

@TomAFrench
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Nope, the changes around ownership are completely hidden to the end user.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

5 participants